PROFESSOR SARQUE is found dead at his private laboratory at Berkeley College, killed by an overdose of a new alkaloid which he had recently discovered. Is his death accident, suicide—or murder? For those who seek thrills, here are thrills in plenty. For those who would exercise their wits, here is a wonderful opportunity.
Just a quick note before I start: I left this blog dormant for a while because I wasn't sure what to do with it. On the one hand, you're not supposed to judge a book by its cover. On the other hand, I was buying these vintage books for their covers (or dust jackets in the case of hardbacks!) So I decided I'd split my commentary into two parts: "Judging the Cover" and "Judging the Book". Of course I'm going to add my usual snippets of random snark as I go along!
So to begin...
Judging the Cover
And my, what a fascinating cover we have to kick off with! There's drama galore as a sinister man appears to be about to hurl an unconscious young woman off the parapets of a castle. Is he a criminal mastermind? A mad scientist? The villain's hapless henchman? Who is the young woman, and how did he get hold of her? This dust jacket could easily double as a contemporary movie poster advertising a horror film. From Universal Studios, maybe, and staring Boris Karloff...
Judging the Book
The "Methuen Clue Stories" series was set up to discover and publish new authors. Dr Cockcaigne is therefore N.E. Davies' first—and possibly only—book. It has the sort of faults a novice writer produces: improbable incident piled on improbable incident, and enough coincidences to supply the complete works of Dickens! On the other hand, it moves at a fast and entertaining pace and there's an excellent surprise twist at the end. I had to go through the book again once I'd read it to realise the clues had been there all along, and I'd missed them!